This may be old news, so forgive me if it is, but I just found out that a group of players broke the rules of baseball and also broke the laws of this country. Evidence was shown to the baseball commissioner, he was convinced of their guilt, but was in a quandary. He was entrusted with the welfare of the game and the game had just come through a major PR disaster and scandal that threatened the existence of the game at the professional level. A few intriguing seasons had won fans back and the game was getting back on its feet. He should have banned these players from the game. Precedent had been set, but if he did so, would it drive a stake in the heart of the game and kill it forever? What would you do? What did he do? Trust the game to endure while purging himself of the evildoers? Cover it up and hope nobody would ever find out? He covered it up. He felt the damage that would be done to the game with another scandal was worse than allowing these players to remain in the game.
What was this scandal? Who was this commissioner? Steroids and Bud Selig??
No, it was throwing games for gamblers and the commissioner was Kennesaw "Mountain" Landis. In the 1920s, on the heels of the 1919 "Black Sox" scandal, a group of players were caught throwing games to get money from gamblers. Landis, the man who banned 8 players for life (including Buck Weaver, who had nothing to do with the scandal, and "Shoeless" Joe Jackson, who played better than anybody and there is controversy as to whether he was part of the scandal or was duped into signing a confession that he, as an illiterate man, couldn't read and was not allowed to get his wife to read to him) for conspiracy to throw games, covered up this incident because he feared the game couldn't take another hit.
What's my point? Selig intentionally covered up steroids positive tests? No. Selig is without blame? No. Selig is half the commissioner Landis was? Certainly not. My point is that this steroid issue, while wrong and needs to be taken care of, is not the first hit to MLB and its popularity. At the turn of the century (1900s), brawls in the stands and public drunkenness led many to call for the banning of pro baseball, the aforementioned 1919 issue, the strike of 1981 was going to kill baseball, the strike of 1994 was the end of it and now this is going to be the end of it. Sure, some people leave after each scandal, but baseball attendance is up each year at ballparks. People point to empty seats and say nobody is coming and point to full stadiums at NFL games as proof people aren't going to games. Let's look at that really quick... for the Patriots to sell out every game, they have to sell for 11 games max, counting playoffs. For the Red Sox (same city), there are 92 games possibly played in Fenway. It's a different animal and half empty seats at a Tuesday evening baseball game can't be compared to a Sunday afternoon football game. Also, I don't want to try to convert anybody into a baseball fan, if you want me to try that, I need to take you to a game to experience it. But if you don't like it, that's cool, we're all different people.
Also, while I'm thinking about it... PUT SHOELESS JOE IN THE HALL OF FAME!!!!